Facebook Connect / Single Sign On platforms

Posted December 3, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Technology

A short note:

I was talking with someone earlier who was excited about the prospect of using their Facebook account to sign on to “all of their favorite web-sites, e-mail, banks …”  This is certainly the direction that Facebook would like you to go.

To borrow a line from the recent Battlestar Gallactica TV series: “This has all happened before, and it will all happen again.”

Indeed, this has all happened before.  We’ve seen Microsoft Passport try (and fail) to provide this very same solution.  Back then, it was lack of trust in “big bad Microsoft” that caused Passport to fail as a Single-Sign-On (SSO) platform.

After Passport, we saw the OpenID take hold.  While not as widely criticized as passport, OpenID has also failed to gather a significant enough following to make it a “success”.  The reasons for this lack of success are many, but it is partly due to it’s complexity both in implementation by web-developers, and in use by the end users.

So, let’s come to the present.  Let’s say Facebook, Google or some other organization comes up with an SSO solution that’s simple and trusted.  I will still not use it, and I would not recommend that you do either.

Why not?  Easy: It is a huge single point of failure!

Let’s take the least likely case first:  Let’s assume that the SSO provider has a catastrophic system failure and they can’t authenticate you.  You would be locked out of every single web-site that you use that ID for.  When you have separate IDs and separate log-ons your interruption is minimal, and limited to one or two systems.  When all of your systems rely on one authentication, and then when that authentication goes down, you lose it all.

The next single point of failure scenario is one that worries me much more:  What happens when your password is compromised?  This could happen today, and when it does you’ve been compromised on the one web-site that you had that password for.  (Unless you were foolish enough to use the same password on every web-site!)  With an SSO solution, you now have lost control of EVERY web-site you use.  Imagine if your bank accounts, e-mail accounts, utility company accounts, and everything used the same SSO for authentication?  You are beginning to see the problem.

Kudos to these companies for their effort to be inventive, but to me, rushing into SSOs are foolhardy at best, and downright dangerous at worst.

My very inappropriate TSA experience at MSP

Posted November 24, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: airline, Travel, TSA

I’ve been skeptical of the new TSA procedures, but have attempted to approach it with fairness and an open mind.  My experience today at MSP (Minneapolis, St. Paul airport) has woefully soured my opinion on this new process and on my opinion of TSA’s professionalism.

Since it was Thanksgiving eve and the weather at MSP was a bit dodgy, I thought it best to arrive early.   Just as I was arriving the TSA was spinning up their “full body scan” machine.  I observed several people in front of me go through it.  I noted that every single person that went through the machine was patted down after they came out of the machine.  I already have concerns about the radiation exposure to frequent flyers due to these machines, so I figured if I am going to be patted down anyway I might as well exercise my right to opt-out of the process, should I be selected.  This would require a pat-down, but if everyone were being patted down anyway, I figured what’s the difference?  It would be like skipping one un-neccessary step.

When my turn came, I was selected for the body-scanner.  I told the agent that I would like to opt-out of the full body scanner.  He looked visibly annoyed as if I were some crazed person with a cause.  (The only cause I am interested in is my health.)  The agent asked me “For what reason are you opting out.”  I explained that I am a very frequent flyer and I have concerns about my health with these brand new machines.  He told me “You are listening to crazy people, there is absolutely ZERO (emphasized) radiation in these machines.”  (This is entirely untrue.)  He said “Go stand over there until we get to you.” I moved over to an area to the side of the line.  I did not move though the metal detector.  I was still in the queue area. My possessions meanwhile went through the X-Ray machine.

I waited about 10-20 minutes while they processed every single person in line behind me. (I can’t be certain of the exact time since my cell phone had already passed through the X-ray and was no longer accessible to me as a time-keeping device.)   I asked twice “Did you all forget about me?” (to which I was told I had to wait for an available agent. I assume the ones that were standing around with no apparent purpose were not “available”).  I also asked “Is someone watching my things while I am stuck on this side” (This question was ignored.)  Eventually, when TSA felt I had waited a sufficiently punitive amount of time I was approached by a fairly pleasant gentleman who once again tried to get me to “opt-in”.  He explained “there is no radiation” and we “are going to have to do an uncomfortable pat-down if you don’t go through the machine”.   I pointed out that they were patting down everyone that went through the machine anyway.  He said “It’s a quicker pat-down with the back of the hand.”  (I took this as an implication being that the front of the hand will be used if I opt out.).  At this point, simply on principle and because I react negatively to pressure, I continued my insistance on opting out.  Please keep in mind that I was pleasant and polite, but firm during this entire process.  The TSA gentleman brought me through security, completely bypassing the metal detector, which was a bit odd to me, and quite different than past-weeks at MSP and certainly different from the procedures at ATL, DCA, and other airports.

Once I arrived on the other side of security and only then, did they bother to go grab my bag and my laptop which was laying there for at least 10-20 minutes, unattended.  The agent now explained to me the pat-down process.  Another female agent walked to our location and informed me that if I had any questions, I should ask the gentleman explaining the process to me.  (TSA needs a second agent to walk over and tell me to ask the first agent if I had any questions?)

I’ve been previously patted down 15-20 times since they have started this new process, but I have never have I had a pat-down like I was subjected to today.  I was told to remove everything from my pockets. I do not think this particular activity was unreasonable considering I was escorted past, and not through the metal detector.  It was at this point that something happened which I thought was only a bad rumor spread by people trying to get some attention for themselves: The agent put his hand inside my pants and felt around.  This was in full-public view of everyone in the screening line!  In an attempt to be fair, I was offered multiple times to be screened in private. Had I known what was about to happen, I certainly would have opted for the private screening.

After the pat-down, the TSA agent ran his gloves for explosive residue.  I was unable to touch my belongings until this was complete.  (I’m glad I was not coming home from a hunting or I may have had gunpowder on me.)

When he was finished, and before the TSA agent informed me that I was free to go, he once again informed me that the machine had “no radiation at all”. (I’m thinking this is a new TSA talking point.) He continued by informing me that the pat-downs “aren’t going away”, so I should “get used to (the body scanners)”.  In my mind, this underlined to me that this whole experience was punitive, and an effort to get me to comply with the body scanners for future flights. I was unfortunate enough to do my normal “opt out” on “National opt out” day.  I suspect the TSA agents took this personally.

If this keeps up, or if the machines become mandatory, I will be flying much less, assuming I can change my job, which is difficult to do in this economy. Flying is a key requirement for my job, and this was a part of my job that I previously enjoyed.  I didn’t feel this way until today.  As I type this, my hands are still visibly shaking by what just happened to me.

I’ve gone through this screening process before.  Indeed, I’ve been patted down many times before.  While awkward, I’ve never felt as if I were targeted with an unpleasant experience because I exercised my legal right to opt out of the body scanners.  I’ve tried to take a balanced view on this entire process and on the TSA.  However, if this is the way TSA wants to win over travelers, they are failing miserably.

If TSA reads this post and wants to verify my story, I am sure there were plenty of cameras and audio recording equipment around the screening area that can corroborate the events described here.

(Unedited draft post)

Visiting a Microsoft Store

Posted November 12, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Microsoft

 

One of my travel assignments has taken me to Minneapolis, MN.  The Mall of America is considered one of the largest shopping complexes in the United States.  Indeed, it is massive.  The Mall of America is located in nearby Bloomington, MN. My visit happened to coincide with the opening of the newest Microsoft Store.  Having never visited a Microsoft store before, I thought I’d drop in and offer my impressions.

Let me first set expectations.  What I did not want to see was a copy of the Apple Store.  I wanted to see some innovation.  I was hoping to catch a glimpse of some sign that Microsoft could still be creative.  Unfortunately with regards to this hope,  I would leave disappointed.

The Microsoft store is located directly across from the Apple Store.  Apparently the designers of this store must have believed that size does matter, because the Microsoft store is about 3 times the size of the nearby Apple store.  The appearance is similar to it’s fruit-named neighbor, albeit a more colorful version.  The familiar Apple fruit-logo is replaced with a block of squares which is (I assume) supposed to make people automatically think of Microsoft.  (See photo)

image1

If you are familiar with the Apple Store then you recognize these features of the Microsoft store:

  • Answer Bar (Microsoft’s version of the Genius Bar)
  • Theatre area in the back with nominal seating
  • Video screens on the walls demonstrating novel ways to use Microsoft products.
  • LCD displays along the outer walls
  • Tables laid out in symmetrical patterns demonstrating various products.
  • Software in the rear left corner of the store.
  • A section for kids to play the XBox (Similar to Apple’s “Kid section: with iMacs)

What do they sell?

Since Apple is (mostly) a hardware company and Microsoft is (mostly) a software company, there has to be some difference right?  Of course!  The Microsoft store has for sale:

- Laptops by Toshiba, Dell, others.  The laptops are sorted into tables holding Small, Medium and Netbook sizes of laptops.  All of the laptops are “scrubbed” of spyware and the “Intel / AMD / tiny gerbil inside” labels have been removed.  If you buy a laptop in the Microsoft store it is repackaged in a spiffy Microsoft Store box.  The hardware that was on-display was unimpressive.  Especially when compared with the slick laptops on display just across the hallway, but also when compared to other laptops on the market. If you needed a basic Windows machine though, you could probably be satisfied with the offerings on display.  Some of them had reminder labels such as “Touch me!  I have a touch screen!”

- XBox:  Obviously this is a popular draw.  This was the only part of the store that was crowded.  The crowd was teenagers using the store as an arcade, but hey, a customer is a customer.

- Software: The store stocks both Microsoft and many 3rd party products.  The number of titles offered was impressive.

- Windows Phone 7:  Several of these phones were on display.  I’m not going to write my impressions, but I will point out that each model, regardless of manufacturer seemed identical.  I’m not sure why they have multiple vendors if they specs are so tight that they leave no room for innovation.  I did like the UI on the Windows Phone line, and some of the sample e-mails were a bit humorous.

- USB Keys that look like R2D2.  (It stuck in my mind, so I thought it was worth mentioning.)

- Kindles.  Yes, the Microsoft Store sells Kindles.  I guess they can say they technically have Tablets for sale.

- Microsoft Surface. I saved this for last.  I spent probably 15 minutes playing with this.  It’s a HUGE table that works sort of like an iPhone.  Just slower than an iPhone, and I needed both arms to work it, and it didn’t do as much as my iPhone.  But: it was a big huge table!!!  I wonder if I can install Space Invaders on it?   If I can then I might like it!

Conclusion:

The Microsoft Store is a solid effort, if not very creative.   They sell an impressive collection of software and I can see the store being my first stop for an XBox.  Nothing impressed me about the selection of laptops that were sold.  There were not enough desktops in stock to mention.  Quite frankly the store left me questioning why I might go to this store instead of a Microcenter, Fry’s or even a Best Buy.  All of these later options I could get to without navigating a huge mall. Unfortunately the store was mostly empty only two days after they opened.  The only people in the store were employees, which outnumbered the teenagers playing on the XBoxes.  This leads me to believe that they very well may have missed the mark.

I wish Microsoft well with these stores, but I think they really need to find something to differentiate themselves.

 

A day of reflection and re-examination

Posted September 8, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Uncategorized

Without more details I’d like to offer my impressions of today:

One of those days that truly makes you appreciate your loved ones.
One of those days that makes you reflect on what is important.
One of those days that makes you wish you said things that should have been said.
Time is not infinite and mortality is painfully real.
Indeed, it has been one of those days that will change the way the rest of one’s life is lived.

One of those days that truly makes you appreciate your loved ones.
One of those days that makes you reflect on what is important.
One of those days that makes you wish you said things that should have been said.
Time is not infinite and mortality is painfully real.
Indeed, it has been one of those days that will change the way the rest of one’s life is lived.

Meebo Emoticons

Posted June 3, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Uncategorized

 

Meebo is one of my favorite instant messaging programs.  Having it cloud based is a bonus in that I can access it, along with my message history and contacts list from any PC I log into.

Today the fine folks at Meebo posted a blog entry with some “secret emotions” that you can use.  Here is that list:

 


(grillz)


(mom)


(vw)


(monkeyking)


(letsgogiants)


(simon)


(pilot)


(prosopagnosiac)


(r2d2)


(sadpanda)


(chicago)


(mikey)


(moto)


(nutella)


(pnb)


(stanford)


(yoga)


(shaka)


(schroedinger)

HTML5 Testing results

Posted May 30, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Firefox, Technology

 

Out of curiosity I wanted to perform some “HTML5 compliant” tests on the various browsers that we use daily.

Fortunately there is a web-site to test such compliance, it’s called www.html5test.com.  I tested aganist the most popular browsers in Windows 7, the iPhone and the iPad.

Here are the results: (Total possible score is 160)

Browser

HTML5 Test Score

Safari – iPhone

113

Firefox – Windows 7

101

Safari – Windows 7

115

Chrome – Windows 7

142

IE8 – Windows 7

19

Opera Mini – iPhone

14

Atomic Browser – iPad

115

Safari – iPad

115

Big winner: Chrome (142), by far!

Big loser: IE8 (19).  I knew HTML5 support would be lacking on IE8, but I didn’t know how bad.  The only browser that scored lower was Opera on the iPhone, but I had no expectation of any decent score there.  I expected IE8 to be at least in the 80s.

Big surprise: FireFox (101).  Since Firefox doesn’t “officially” support HTML5 I would have guessed it’s score to be just slightly better than IE8.  But, it’s 101 score places it just marginally behind Safari.

GMail annoyances

Posted May 29, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: iPhone, Mac, Outlook, Push e-mail

 

Recently GMail annoys me more than it pleases me.  I feel that the only reason that I’m keeping it around is for it’s amazing mail search tool.  Beyond that I find it one of the most annoying mail systems I’ve used.

My primary desktop platform is Windows (Outlook mail client) and the Mac (mail.app.)  My primary mobile device is the iPhone and iPad.  Occasionally I’ll be spotted using a Windows Mobile device.

Things that I do not like about GMail:

  • Deleting a message from the mobile client (iPhone, Windows Mobile, etc) simply “archives” a message and doesn’t delete it.
  • When I attempt to view picture attachments on the iPhone (using the Exchange Activesync protocol) the picture often does not download, forcing me to go and use the Mobile Web interface.  This brings me to this problem.
  • The mobile web interface often doesn’t show inline images, leaving me to guess what is supposed to be in the message.
  • Using the Exchange ActiveSync protocol to get “push” e-mail on your iPhone is spotty.  Sometimes it works, sometimes it does not. (Minor issue, but still)
  • Often, moving a message to a “folder” results in an error that “my operation could not be performed” or something like that, once again forcing me to go back to the mobile web interface.
  • Labels / Threaded views do not play well with desktop and mobile clients through the IMAP interface.  This often throws my Outlook client (PC) or my Mail.app client (Mac) into fits.

It’s a short list, but it’s a list of minor issues that are front and center during my daily work-cycle. 

I love GMail search.  I can find a message from anytime with minimal effort.  I can do this on the desktop as well using Windows Search against my Outlook database or on the Mac using Spotlight.  But, these desktop solutions don’t help me when I’m on the road and using a public PC. 

Do any of you have an alternative to GMail that you use? 

 

Update:  Additional blog articles that also find issues with GMail ..

http://www.intuitive.com/blog/gmail_on_apple_iphone_sucks.html

http://theblogthatnoonereads.davegrijalva.com/2007/07/03/gmail-sucks-on-the-iphone/

http://www.welcometofreshmanyear.com/b/archives/1255

http://menga.net/5390

Some lifestyle changes and dangers of the road ..

Posted May 23, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Family, Personal

 

I have not blogged about personal life issues for a very long time.    Every road warrior knows (or soon learns) living on the road does take a toll on your personal life, your habits and your mannerisms.  After much thought, I’ve decided that changes that I’ve  recently made in my life were important enough to share.  Perhaps as a result you’ll all get a better picture of my character. (I just hope you all don’t think less of me after this article.)

One of the hazards of any job that requires you to live on the road for many weeks at a time,  in various hotels and cities around the world is the inevitable boredom that can result.  You get up, you go to work and you return to the hotel.  There is nobody there to greet you, or to talk too you.  There is very little to do.  After reading dozens of books, even reading gets boring.  Now, while I’m sure that everyone deals with this situation differently, one of the more popular ways to deal with it has been to find a local pub.  Yes, a bar, saloon, watering-hole or whatever you want to call it.  It’s an age-old pastime popularized by such TV series as “Cheers”.  You find a reasonable establishment, slide up a seat, order a brew or other beverage of choice.  Before you know it you are engaged in conversation with some other person.  Before you know it, a small group is solving the worlds problems.  It sounds silly, but it kills time and to be clear, I’ve met many nice and genuinely interesting people with just such a pastime.  Kept in moderation, there is nothing wrong with this activity.  But there are hazards if you aren’t careful. 

After several years of this you can easily find yourself turning 1-2 drinks into 3-4.  If you are in your hotel bar, then no harm because you can just walk up to your room.  A group of people “shooting the crap” will, inevitably begin to tell “fish-stories” after 3-4 drinks.  What this entails is starting with a small fragment of truth and exaggerating it to the point that it’s a very interesting work of pure fiction.  This typically involves stories about cars, women, or, well … fishing.  I used to see through this, and laugh. It is in fact, harmless.  Then, I started telling a “fish-story” myself.  Why?  I suppose it was a failed attempt to make myself more interesting. (It’s easy to forget that you already ARE interesting.) I felt like a fool afterwards.  Harmless?  To everyone else, yes.  To me?  I didn’t like that I just fabricated a story.  (In my case, I actually told it to a friend, and I doubt that the story went over nearly as well as I thought it might have.

This led me to begin shutting my mouth and listening more.  In fact, I went back to drinking 1 or 2 drinks and just observing my fellow travelers, sort of like an outsider.  I was less than impressed.  I tried to visualize myself as part of this same group sitting around telling fish stories while killing off my brain-cells before heading back up to an empty hotel room.  The thought was depressing. 

More recently I’ve been spending time at home.  I have been off the road for about two months.  During this time I spent a few nights going back to my local pub to chat with people I’ve known for years.  While we’ve never told “fish-stories” to each other, and while we have rarely had more than 1 or 2 beers in an evening, I did look at the situation in an entirely different light.  I used to love the social aspect of my “local cheers”.  Now I’m bored with it.  We don’t talk about anything different, and the obligatory question “What’s new?” solicits the same response each evening.  My pastime to kill the boredom had itself become boring!  Worse, I was paying good money to sit there and be bored.  Yes, it was a great place to watch a game, but for less money I can get the game at home. 

After coming to this realization and after pondering it for a few weeks I started to ask myself what is it that was really bringing me happiness? The answer is the same thing as always; my family.  While this doesn’t help me as much on the road, it certainly was enough justification for me turning in my membership card to the “barstool club”. 

I wanted to re-focus on the most important aspect of my life, and while I’m at it, improve my health!  So,my wife and I have decided to give up  alcohol.  We’ll probably still occasionally have a glass of wine with dinner, but we are at the point we don’t need wine or drink to “take the edge off”.  I’m personally at the point where I can hang out with my friends (even at a bar) and be content with a diet cola or a glass of water.  (I’ll bet I become the popular guy to drive people home.)   With the money I’m saving I’ve purchased a set of web-cams so that I can interact with the kids while I’m on the road.  This should make going back to the hotel room that much less boring.  For the remaining time I’ll be using the hotel gym, or maybe even reading some books on the new iPad

In conclusion; I feel it is a great thing to periodically re-examine your life. There will be times where you like where it’s going.  There will also be times when you look and say “wow, I really took a wrong turn there, let’s go back and find out where, so I can get back on the right road." I am not always happy with some of the choices I’ve made.  Some have just left me unfulfilled.  Other choices have made me feel foolish. 

I have a wonderful and blessed life.   I want to get the most out of it, and give the most of myself to those I care about.   I’m really looking forward to refocusing my energy into other areas of my life.  I’m sure some of my fellow travelers can relate. 

To my friends, if you want to meet up for a drink, that’s fine.  I hope you don’t mind if I order a diet-cola.  :-)

Video Editing on Windows 7

Posted May 10, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Photography, Video Editing, Windows

 

Once upon a time my primary machine was a MacBook Pro.  Due to some unfortunate circumstances and job requirements, I was forced to change to using a Dell Latitude E6400.  While the hardware was very nicely equipped, I no longer had the option to use OSX as my operating system.  While Windows 7 is a huge improvement over past Microsoft Operating System efforts, and while Windows 7 is more than adequate in most areas, it seems to fall short in the areas of media management, consisting of  photo management and video editing.  The Mac had iPhoto and iMovie.  The Windows counterparts to these apps seem quite lacking.

For Photo Management I’ve been using Windows Live Photo Gallery.  It’s adequate and certainly usable, unless you want to make a photo book or some other gift idea.  But more on that later,  right now my concern is video.

Microsoft’s latest video editing effort is Windows Live Movie Maker.  Unfortunately, while obviously easier to use than it’s predecessor many of the advanced tools have been stripped out of it, so it is also far less capable.  My biggest beef with it is that I can only export my final product to WMV files.  This seriously limits what I can do with it.  For example: I can’t import it back into my Flip video camera or even my iPhone.  I even have problems using it with some DVD burning software.

Is anyone else doing any video editing on Windows 7?  What products are you using?  If you are using Windows Live Movie Maker, do you have any recommended tools to convert WMV to MP4 or h.264?

Evernote or OneNote

Posted February 18, 2010 by ellisz
Categories: Cloud, Technology

 

Evernote is one of my most used “cloud” apps.  I use Evernote on my PC, Mac or iPhone at least a dozen times a day.  Evernote really has become an extension of my brain. 

As I was going through my PC tonight I opened my OneNote application.  I found all of my customer notes going back about 4 to 5 years.  I think OneNote fell out of favor with me when I moved to Evernote.

For me, Evernote was far more useful to me because of it’s cross-platform abilities and it’s amazing synchronization engine.  Evernote has terrific handwriting recognition. Write a note on a napkin, take a snapshot of it or scan it and then import it into Evernote.  Evernote will allow you to search on that handwritten text.  Very cool technology indeed!

Both Evernote and OneNote have decent Ink support (if you have a Tablet PC or a Watcom tablet).  OneNote theoretically supports searching for words in audio recordings.  I say theoretically because I can’t get this feature to work. 

When I opened OneNote tonight I remembered how much I preferred the OneNote user-interface over Evernote. It’s much more of a “paper feel”. It allows me much more formatting and layout freedom to organize my thoughts in OneNote.  If OneNote had the sync and cross platform features of Evernote it wouldn’t be a contest.  But, it doesn’t.  Therefore Evernote remains my very essential thought and idea organization tool. 

What do you use and why? 


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.